Skip to Content Skip to Navigation
FREE SHIPPING over $49, or flat $5 shipping, you choose. Get Code
Accessibility
Help
1-877-867-1920 Mon thru Fri 9 am - 5 pm EST
Wishing Well
Quick Order
0
$0.00
Track Order Customer Service Our Company Ways to Shop Wishing Well

Contact Support

1-877-867-1920 Mon thru Fri 9 am - 5 pm EST

Email Us

Accessibility

  1. Home
  2. Clearance
  3. Mix and Match
  4. Pencils

pencils

1-14 of 14 items
Make The Grade Pencils - 12 pencils.
Make The Grade Pencils - 12 pencils.
$4.99
(5.0)

Get it Jul 24, 2025

Order in the next 19 hrs and 3 mins
Happy Birthday Pencils - set of 12 pencils.
Happy Birthday Pencils - set of 12 pencils.
$4.99
(5.0)

Get it Jul 24, 2025

Order in the next 19 hrs and 3 mins
Birthday Cake Scented Pencils - 12 scented pencils
Birthday Cake Scented Pencils - 12 scented pencils
$4.99
(4.6)

Get it Jul 24, 2025

Order in the next 19 hrs and 3 mins
Grade-Specific Welcome Pencils - 12 Pencils for K, 1st, 2nd or 3rd Grade
Grade-Specific Welcome Pencils - 12 Pencils for K, 1st, 2nd or 3rd Grade
$4.99
(5.0)

Get it Jul 24, 2025

Order in the next 19 hrs and 3 mins
100th Day Pencil - 12 pencils.
100th Day Pencil - 12 pencils.
$5.99
(3.6)

Get it Jul 24, 2025

Order in the next 19 hrs and 3 mins
Happy Birthday Multi-Colored Pencils - 12 pencils
Happy Birthday Multi-Colored Pencils - 12 pencils
$4.99
(4.9)

Get it Jul 24, 2025

Order in the next 19 hrs and 3 mins
Happy Birthday Fiesta Pencils - 12 pencils
Happy Birthday Fiesta Pencils - 12 pencils
$4.99
(5.0)

Get it Jul 24, 2025

Order in the next 19 hrs and 3 mins
Welcome To My Class Pencils - Sharpened - 12 sharpened pencils
Welcome To My Class Pencils - Sharpened - 12 sharpened pencils
$4.99
(5.0)

Get it Jul 24, 2025

Order in the next 19 hrs and 3 mins
Welcome Back To School Pencils - 12 pencils
Welcome Back To School Pencils - 12 pencils
$4.99
(5.0)

Get it Jul 24, 2025

Order in the next 19 hrs and 3 mins
Jumbo Kindergarten Pencils
Jumbo Kindergarten Pencils
$4.99
(4.9)

Get it Jul 24, 2025

Order in the next 19 hrs and 3 mins
100th Day Of School Twinkler Pencils - 12 pencils
100th Day Of School Twinkler Pencils - 12 pencils
$4.99
(5.0)

Get it Jul 24, 2025

Order in the next 19 hrs and 3 mins
Really Good Stuff® Paws Pencils - 12 pencils
Really Good Stuff® Paws Pencils - 12 pencils
$4.99
(5.0)

Get it Jul 24, 2025

Order in the next 19 hrs and 3 mins
Super Reader Pencils - 12 pencils
Super Reader Pencils - 12 pencils
$4.99

Get it Jul 24, 2025

Order in the next 19 hrs and 3 mins
Dr. Seuss™ Giant Eraser Pencils - 36 pencils
Dr. Seuss™ Giant Eraser Pencils - 36 pencils
$36.99
(4.7)

Get it Jul 24, 2025

Order in the next 19 hrs and 3 mins
Save when you buy 3 or more 12 Packs of Our Best Pencils!
Recommended For You
Deluxe Spiral Draw and Write Journals (Kids Cover) - Pre-K - K - 6 journals
Deluxe Spiral Draw and Write Journals (Kids Cover) - Pre-K - K - 6 journals
$33.99
My Kindergarten Journal - Set of 12
My Kindergarten Journal - Set of 12
$32.99
Once-A-Week Take-Home Folders - 12 folders
Once-A-Week Take-Home Folders - 12 folders
$29.99
Really Good Stuff® Spiral Landscape Draw And Write Journals (112 Page) - Set of 6
Really Good Stuff® Spiral Landscape Draw And Write Journals (112 Page) - Set of 6
$29.99
Store More® Deep-Pocket Chair Pockets –6 Pack – Black
Store More® Deep-Pocket Chair Pockets –6 Pack – Black
$48.99
Really Good Stuff® Intermediate Math Resource 4-Pocket Folders - Set of 12
Really Good Stuff® Intermediate Math Resource 4-Pocket Folders - Set of 12
$38.99
Standard Privacy Shields - Set of 12 - 6 Group Colors - Star and Swirl - Matte
Standard Privacy Shields - Set of 12 - 6 Group Colors - Star and Swirl - Matte
$44.99
Softcover My First Grade Journals - Set Of 12
Softcover My First Grade Journals - Set Of 12
$32.99
Store More® Deep-Pocket Chair Pockets – 6 Pack – Navy/ Green
Store More® Deep-Pocket Chair Pockets – 6 Pack – Navy/ Green
$49.99
Homework Folders - 12 folders
Homework Folders - 12 folders
$29.99
Deluxe Spiral Draw and Write Journals (Star Cover) -K-2 - Set of 6
Deluxe Spiral Draw and Write Journals (Star Cover) -K-2 - Set of 6
$32.99
Classwork Folders - 12 folders
Classwork Folders - 12 folders
$29.99
Really Good Stuff® My Writing Word Journals - Set of 12
Really Good Stuff® My Writing Word Journals - Set of 12
$16.99
Important Papers Folders - 12 folders
Important Papers Folders - 12 folders
$29.99
Desktop Helper™ 12" Self-Adhesive Vinyl Sleeves - Set Of 12
Desktop Helper™ 12" Self-Adhesive Vinyl Sleeves - Set Of 12
$24.99
Related Items
neon eraser crayon erasers ready set 100th day 100th day collections 100th day glasses and crowns kit
Related Categories
plastic desktops pencil sharpener science stem kits centers beach balls graduation washable markers
Related Products
Close
Ticonderoga® Neon Erasers - Set of 30
Ticonderoga® Neon Erasers - Set of 30
Ticonderoga® Neon Erasers bring a little fun to

View More
Ticonderoga® Neon Erasers bring a little fun to your home, school or office, while still delivering the same great Ticonderoga® performance you expect. Beveled edges give you ultimate control over what you remove from the surface. These soft, latex-free neon ...

View Full Product Description
Close
Quiet-Sharp™ Classroom Electric Pencil Sharpener - Blue -
Quiet-Sharp™ Classroom Electric Pencil Sharpener - Blue -
Built with classroom demands in mind, this sharpener

View More
Built with classroom demands in mind, this sharpener will help students sharpen their pencils quickly, quietly, and safely. A super duty motor with thermal overload protection will assure quiet durability that can withstand strenuous classroom use. The tamper-proof MagnaSafe™ shutoff ...

View Full Product Description
Close
Really Good Stuff® My 100th Day Collection Ready-To-Decorate®
Really Good Stuff® My 100th Day Collection Ready-To-Decorate®
The centerpiece of this poster is the outline

View More
The centerpiece of this poster is the outline of a blank tee shirt, which can be filled in with items collected for 100th Day. The poster is sturdy enough for small items, such as pasta, cereal, paper clips, or candy, ...

View Full Product Description