Skip to Content Skip to Navigation
FREE SHIPPING on orders over $49
FREE SHIPPING on orders over $49
FREE SHIPPING on orders over $49
Accessibility
Help
1-877-867-1920 Mon thru Fri 9 am - 5 pm EST
Wishing Well
Quick Order
0
$0.00
Track Order Customer Service Our Company Ways to Shop Wishing Well

Contact Support

1-877-867-1920 Mon thru Fri 9 am - 5 pm EST

Email Us

Accessibility

  1. Home
  2. Clearance
  3. Mix and Match
  4. Pencils

pencils

1-24 of 30 items
Make The Grade Pencils - 12 pencils.
Make The Grade Pencils - 12 pencils.
$5.23
(5.0)

Get it May 08, 2025

Order in the next 14 hrs and 11 mins
Happy Birthday Pencils - set of 12 pencils.
Happy Birthday Pencils - set of 12 pencils.
$4.99
(5.0)

Get it May 08, 2025

Order in the next 14 hrs and 11 mins
Birthday Cake Scented Pencils - 12 scented pencils
Birthday Cake Scented Pencils - 12 scented pencils
$4.99
(4.6)

Get it May 08, 2025

Order in the next 14 hrs and 11 mins
Welcome Back To School Pencils - 12 pencils
Welcome Back To School Pencils - 12 pencils
$4.29
(5.0)

Get it May 08, 2025

Order in the next 14 hrs and 11 mins
Really Good Stuff® Fidgets Pencils Classroom Pack
Really Good Stuff® Fidgets Pencils Classroom Pack
$59.99

Get it May 08, 2025

Order in the next 14 hrs and 11 mins
Happy Birthday Multi-Colored Pencils - 12 pencils
Happy Birthday Multi-Colored Pencils - 12 pencils
$4.99
(4.9)

Get it May 08, 2025

Order in the next 14 hrs and 11 mins
Cat In The Hat Pencils - 12 pack
Clearance
Cat In The Hat Pencils - 12 pack
$2.99 $4.99
You save: $2.00 (40.0%)
(4.6)

Get it May 08, 2025

Order in the next 14 hrs and 11 mins
100th Day Of School Twinkler Pencils - 12 pencils
100th Day Of School Twinkler Pencils - 12 pencils
$4.99
(5.0)

Get it May 08, 2025

Order in the next 14 hrs and 11 mins
Welcome To My Class Pencils - Sharpened - 12 sharpened pencils
Welcome To My Class Pencils - Sharpened - 12 sharpened pencils
$4.99
(5.0)

Get it May 08, 2025

Order in the next 14 hrs and 11 mins
Happy Birthday Fiesta Pencils - 12 pencils
Happy Birthday Fiesta Pencils - 12 pencils
$4.99
(5.0)

Get it May 08, 2025

Order in the next 14 hrs and 11 mins
Really Good Stuff® Bubble-Gum Scented Pencils - 12 pencils
Really Good Stuff® Bubble-Gum Scented Pencils - 12 pencils
$4.99
(3.8)

Get it May 08, 2025

Order in the next 14 hrs and 11 mins
Really Good Stuff® Kindness Counts Pencils - 12 pencils
Really Good Stuff® Kindness Counts Pencils - 12 pencils
$5.24
(3.0)

Get it May 08, 2025

Order in the next 14 hrs and 11 mins
Super Reader Pencils - 12 pencils
Super Reader Pencils - 12 pencils
$4.99

Get it May 08, 2025

Order in the next 14 hrs and 11 mins
I Am 100 Days Brighter! Pencils - 12 pencils
I Am 100 Days Brighter! Pencils - 12 pencils
$5.99
(3.0)

Get it May 08, 2025

Order in the next 14 hrs and 11 mins
Growth Mindset Pencils
Growth Mindset Pencils
$4.99
(5.0)

Get it May 08, 2025

Order in the next 14 hrs and 11 mins
Dr. Seuss™ Rainbow Writer Pencils - 12 pencils with toppers
Dr. Seuss™ Rainbow Writer Pencils - 12 pencils with toppers
$22.99
(5.0)

Get it May 08, 2025

Order in the next 14 hrs and 11 mins
100th Day Pencil - 12 pencils.
100th Day Pencil - 12 pencils.
$5.99
(3.6)

Get it May 08, 2025

Order in the next 14 hrs and 11 mins
Really Good Stuff® Paws Pencils - 12 pencils
Really Good Stuff® Paws Pencils - 12 pencils
$4.99
(5.0)

Get it May 08, 2025

Order in the next 14 hrs and 11 mins
Colorations® No.2 Pencils Value Pack - Set of 144
Colorations® No.2 Pencils Value Pack - Set of 144
$39.99

Get it May 12, 2025

Order in the next 14 hrs and 11 mins
Colorations® Sustainable Regular Size Colored Pencils Value Pack - Set of 240
Colorations® Sustainable Regular Size Colored Pencils Value Pack - Set of 240
$63.99
(5.0)

Get it May 12, 2025

Order in the next 14 hrs and 11 mins
Colorations® Stubby Chubby Colored Pencils - Set of 48
Colorations® Stubby Chubby Colored Pencils - Set of 48
$19.99

Get it May 12, 2025

Order in the next 14 hrs and 11 mins
Colorations® Regular Colored Pencils, 12 Colors, 2 Sets
Colorations® Regular Colored Pencils, 12 Colors, 2 Sets
$6.28

Get it May 12, 2025

Order in the next 14 hrs and 11 mins
Colorations® No.2 Pencils - Set of 12
Sale
Colorations® No.2 Pencils - Set of 12
$4.49

Get it May 12, 2025

Order in the next 14 hrs and 11 mins
Colorations® Primary Pencils - With Erasers, Set of 144
Colorations® Primary Pencils - With Erasers, Set of 144
$52.99

Get it May 12, 2025

Order in the next 14 hrs and 11 mins
Save when you buy 3 or more 12 Packs of Our Best Pencils!
Recommended For You
Really Good Stuff® Stackable Letter-Size Wire Rack™ - Boho
Really Good Stuff® Stackable Letter-Size Wire Rack™ - Boho
$95.99
Family Engagement Reading - Read, Write and Play Pack - Second Grade
Family Engagement Reading - Read, Write and Play Pack - Second Grade
$29.99
Colorations® Construction Paper Smart Pack 9"x12" - 600 Sheets
Colorations® Construction Paper Smart Pack 9"x12" - 600 Sheets
$34.99
Family Engagement Math – Practice, Solve and Play Pack - First Grade
Family Engagement Math – Practice, Solve and Play Pack - First Grade
$29.99
Really Good Stuff® Group Colors For 6 - Classroom Paper Baskets - 6 baskets
Really Good Stuff® Group Colors For 6 - Classroom Paper Baskets - 6 baskets
$48.99
Store More® Medium Book Pouches And Labels - Black With Neon Trim - Set Of 12
Store More® Medium Book Pouches And Labels - Black With Neon Trim - Set Of 12
$88.99
Family Engagement Reading - Read, Write and Play Pack - Kindergarten
Family Engagement Reading - Read, Write and Play Pack - Kindergarten
$29.99
Family Engagement Reading - Read, Write and Play Pack - Third Grade
Family Engagement Reading - Read, Write and Play Pack - Third Grade
$29.99
Family Engagement Math – Practice, Solve and Play Pack - Kindergarten
Family Engagement Math – Practice, Solve and Play Pack - Kindergarten
$29.99
Family Engagement Math – Practice, Solve and Play Pack - Third Grade
Family Engagement Math – Practice, Solve and Play Pack - Third Grade
$29.99
Family Engagement Reading - Read, Write and Play Pack - First Grade
Family Engagement Reading - Read, Write and Play Pack - First Grade
$29.99
Really Good Stuff® Re-Markable™ Dry Erase Sleeves - 30 Pack - 6 Color Classroom Pack
Really Good Stuff® Re-Markable™ Dry Erase Sleeves - 30 Pack - 6 Color Classroom Pack
$64.99
Family Engagement Reading - Read, Write and Play Pack - Fourth Grade
Family Engagement Reading - Read, Write and Play Pack - Fourth Grade
$29.99
Family Engagement Reading - Read, Write and Play Pack -Upper Grades
Family Engagement Reading - Read, Write and Play Pack -Upper Grades
$24.99
Two-Sided Primary-Lined Dry Erase Boards - Set Of 12
Two-Sided Primary-Lined Dry Erase Boards - Set Of 12
$49.99
Related Items
sharpie accent highlighter set ticonderoga my first tri write pencils electric classroom pencil sharpener wood cased pencils ticonderoga pencil
Related Categories
cupcake pencils and erasers colorations pencil science stem kits centers beach balls graduation blue rugs
Related Products
Close
Quiet-Sharp™ Classroom Electric Pencil Sharpener - Blue -
Quiet-Sharp™ Classroom Electric Pencil Sharpener - Blue -
Built with classroom demands in mind, this sharpener

View More
Built with classroom demands in mind, this sharpener will help students sharpen their pencils quickly, quietly, and safely. A super duty motor with thermal overload protection will assure quiet durability that can withstand strenuous classroom use. The tamper-proof MagnaSafe™ shutoff ...

View Full Product Description
Close
Ticonderoga® My First Tri-Write Pencils
Ticonderoga® My First Tri-Write Pencils
This large size (13/32”) No. 2 pencils in

View More
This large size (13/32”) No. 2 pencils in triangular shapes are easy for small hands to hold making them ideal for children in the early stages of their writing development. The naturally ergonomic shapes help teach correct pencil grip. Thick ...

View Full Product Description
Close
Sharpie® Accent® Highlighters - Set of 12
Sharpie® Accent® Highlighters - Set of 12
Draw attention to artwork, crafts, presentations and writing

View More
Draw attention to artwork, crafts, presentations and writing projects with this set of 12 assorted highlighters. Highlighters feature Smear Guard® technology to resists smearing when used on top of pen and marker inks.Great for highlighting and underliningDurable and versatile chisel ...

View Full Product Description