Skip to Content Skip to Navigation
FREE SHIPPING over $49, or flat $5 shipping, you choose. Get Code
Accessibility
Help
1-877-867-1920 Mon thru Fri 9 am - 5 pm EST
Wishing Well
Quick Order
0
$0.00
Track Order Customer Service Our Company Ways to Shop Wishing Well

Contact Support

1-877-867-1920 Mon thru Fri 9 am - 5 pm EST

Email Us

Accessibility

  1. Home
  2. Clearance
  3. Mix and Match
  4. Pencils

pencils

1-24 of 35 items
Make The Grade Pencils - 12 pencils.
Make The Grade Pencils - 12 pencils.
$4.99
(5.0)

Get it Jul 09, 2025

Order in the next 8 hrs and 48 mins
Grade-Specific Welcome Pencils - 12 Pencils for K, 1st, 2nd or 3rd Grade
Grade-Specific Welcome Pencils - 12 Pencils for K, 1st, 2nd or 3rd Grade
$4.99
(5.0)

Get it Jul 09, 2025

Order in the next 8 hrs and 48 mins
Happy Birthday Pencils - set of 12 pencils.
Happy Birthday Pencils - set of 12 pencils.
$4.99
(5.0)

Get it Jul 09, 2025

Order in the next 8 hrs and 48 mins
Happy Birthday Multi-Colored Pencils - 12 pencils
Happy Birthday Multi-Colored Pencils - 12 pencils
$4.99
(4.9)

Get it Jul 09, 2025

Order in the next 8 hrs and 48 mins
Welcome To My Class Pencils - Sharpened - 12 sharpened pencils
Welcome To My Class Pencils - Sharpened - 12 sharpened pencils
$4.99
(5.0)

Get it Jul 09, 2025

Order in the next 8 hrs and 48 mins
Happy Birthday Fiesta Pencils - 12 pencils
Happy Birthday Fiesta Pencils - 12 pencils
$4.99
(5.0)

Get it Jul 09, 2025

Order in the next 8 hrs and 48 mins
Birthday Cake Scented Pencils - 12 scented pencils
Birthday Cake Scented Pencils - 12 scented pencils
$4.99
(4.6)

Get it Jul 09, 2025

Order in the next 8 hrs and 48 mins
100th Day Pencil - 12 pencils.
100th Day Pencil - 12 pencils.
$5.99
(3.6)

Get it Jul 09, 2025

Order in the next 8 hrs and 48 mins
Welcome Back To School Pencils - 12 pencils
Welcome Back To School Pencils - 12 pencils
$4.99
(5.0)

Get it Jul 09, 2025

Order in the next 8 hrs and 48 mins
100th Day Of School Twinkler Pencils - 12 pencils
100th Day Of School Twinkler Pencils - 12 pencils
$4.99
(5.0)

Get it Jul 09, 2025

Order in the next 8 hrs and 48 mins
Star Student Pizzazz Pencils - 12 pencils
Star Student Pizzazz Pencils - 12 pencils
$4.99

Get it Jul 09, 2025

Order in the next 8 hrs and 48 mins
Jumbo Kindergarten Pencils
Jumbo Kindergarten Pencils
$4.99
(4.9)

Get it Jul 09, 2025

Order in the next 8 hrs and 48 mins
Growth Mindset Pencils
Growth Mindset Pencils
$4.99
(5.0)

Get it Jul 09, 2025

Order in the next 8 hrs and 48 mins
Colorations® Sustainable Regular Size Colored Pencils Value Pack - Set of 240
Colorations® Sustainable Regular Size Colored Pencils Value Pack - Set of 240
$63.99
(5.0)

Get it Jul 09, 2025

Order in the next 8 hrs and 48 mins
Really Good Stuff® Paws Pencils - 12 pencils
Really Good Stuff® Paws Pencils - 12 pencils
$4.99
(5.0)

Get it Jul 09, 2025

Order in the next 8 hrs and 48 mins
Super Reader Pencils - 12 pencils
Super Reader Pencils - 12 pencils
$4.99

Get it Jul 09, 2025

Order in the next 8 hrs and 48 mins
I Am 100 Days Brighter! Pencils - 12 pencils
I Am 100 Days Brighter! Pencils - 12 pencils
$5.99
(3.0)

Get it Jul 09, 2025

Order in the next 8 hrs and 48 mins
Really Good Stuff® Kindness Counts Pencils - 12 pencils
Really Good Stuff® Kindness Counts Pencils - 12 pencils
$5.99
(3.0)

Get it Jul 09, 2025

Order in the next 8 hrs and 48 mins
Colorations® Stubby Chubby Colored Pencils - Set of 48
Colorations® Stubby Chubby Colored Pencils - Set of 48
$19.99

Get it Jul 09, 2025

Order in the next 8 hrs and 48 mins
Really Good Stuff® Bubble-Gum Scented Pencils - 12 pencils
Really Good Stuff® Bubble-Gum Scented Pencils - 12 pencils
$4.99
(3.8)

Get it Jul 09, 2025

Order in the next 8 hrs and 48 mins
I Am 100 Days Brighter Pencils - Set Of 144
I Am 100 Days Brighter Pencils - Set Of 144
$39.99

Get it Jul 09, 2025

Order in the next 8 hrs and 48 mins
Colorations® Color Pencils, 6 Packs
Colorations® Color Pencils, 6 Packs
$18.99

Get it Jul 09, 2025

Order in the next 8 hrs and 48 mins
Dr. Seuss™ Giant Eraser Pencils - 36 pencils
Dr. Seuss™ Giant Eraser Pencils - 36 pencils
$36.99
(4.7)

Get it Jul 09, 2025

Order in the next 8 hrs and 48 mins
Really Good Stuff® Fidgets Pencils Classroom Pack
Really Good Stuff® Fidgets Pencils Classroom Pack
$59.99

Get it Jul 09, 2025

Order in the next 8 hrs and 48 mins
Save when you buy 3 or more 12 Packs of Our Best Pencils!
Recommended For You
Really Good Stuff® Spiral Landscape Draw And Write Journals (112 Page) - Set of 6
Really Good Stuff® Spiral Landscape Draw And Write Journals (112 Page) - Set of 6
$29.99
1430NB 14.1" 1920x 1080 IPS High Resolution, 4GB/64GB Windows Laptop
1430NB 14.1" 1920x 1080 IPS High Resolution, 4GB/64GB Windows Laptop
$299.99
My Kindergarten Journal - Set of 12
My Kindergarten Journal - Set of 12
$32.99
Deluxe Spiral Draw and Write Journals (Kids Cover) - Pre-K - K - 6 journals
Deluxe Spiral Draw and Write Journals (Kids Cover) - Pre-K - K - 6 journals
$33.99
Store More® Deep-Pocket Chair Pockets –6 Pack – Black
Store More® Deep-Pocket Chair Pockets –6 Pack – Black
$48.99
Store More® Medium Book Pouches - Black With Neon Trim - Set Of 36
Store More® Medium Book Pouches - Black With Neon Trim - Set Of 36
$259.99
Family Engagement Reading - Read, Write and Play Pack - Kindergarten
Family Engagement Reading - Read, Write and Play Pack - Kindergarten
$29.99
Homework Envelopes With Hook-And-Loop Closures - Grouping Colors - 12 envelopes
Homework Envelopes With Hook-And-Loop Closures - Grouping Colors - 12 envelopes
$39.99
Two-Sided Primary-Lined Dry Erase Boards - Set Of 12
Two-Sided Primary-Lined Dry Erase Boards - Set Of 12
$49.99
Store More® Large Book Pouches - Black With Neon Trim - Set Of 36
Store More® Large Book Pouches - Black With Neon Trim - Set Of 36
$299.99
Reusable Classroom Take-Home Bags with Zip Top - Set of 30
Reusable Classroom Take-Home Bags with Zip Top - Set of 30
$18.49
Early Childhood Take Home Folders - 12 folders
Early Childhood Take Home Folders - 12 folders
$29.99
Deluxe Chair Pockets with Pencil Case – 6 Pack – Black/Turquoise
Deluxe Chair Pockets with Pencil Case – 6 Pack – Black/Turquoise
$49.99
Deluxe Spiral Draw and Write Journals (Star Cover) -K-2 - Set of 6
Deluxe Spiral Draw and Write Journals (Star Cover) -K-2 - Set of 6
$32.99
Softcover My Second Grade Journals - Set of 12
Softcover My Second Grade Journals - Set of 12
$32.99
Related Items
crayon erasers 100 days brighter wood ticonderoga pencils 100th day collections 100th day celebration crown
Related Categories
ticonderoga® pencil beach balls graduation really good stuff desktop helpers green rugs kindness counts
Related Products
Close
Ticonderoga® Neon Erasers - Set of 30
Ticonderoga® Neon Erasers - Set of 30
Ticonderoga® Neon Erasers bring a little fun to

View More
Ticonderoga® Neon Erasers bring a little fun to your home, school or office, while still delivering the same great Ticonderoga® performance you expect. Beveled edges give you ultimate control over what you remove from the surface. These soft, latex-free neon ...

View Full Product Description
Close
Ready-To-Decorate® First Day-Last Day Letters Kit - set
Ready-To-Decorate® First Day-Last Day Letters Kit - set
Give students these letters at the beginning of

View More
Give students these letters at the beginning of school to fill in with information about themselves, and add a photo or self-portrait. When they're finished, ask them to fold them up and place them in the matching envelopes. Then collect ...

View Full Product Description
Close
Sharpie® Accent® Highlighters - Set of 12
Sharpie® Accent® Highlighters - Set of 12
Draw attention to artwork, crafts, presentations and writing

View More
Draw attention to artwork, crafts, presentations and writing projects with this set of 12 assorted highlighters. Highlighters feature Smear Guard® technology to resists smearing when used on top of pen and marker inks.Great for highlighting and underliningDurable and versatile chisel ...

View Full Product Description