Skip to Content Skip to Navigation
FREE SHIPPING on orders over $79 OR $5 Flat Rate on orders under $79!
FREE SHIPPING on orders over $79 OR $5 Flat Rate on orders under $79!
FREE SHIPPING on orders over $79 OR $5 Flat Rate on orders under $79!
Accessibility
Help
1-877-867-1920 Mon thru Fri 9 am - 5 pm EST
Wishing Well
Quick Order
0
$0.00
Track Order Customer Service Our Company Ways to Shop Wishing Well

Contact Support

1-877-867-1920 Mon thru Fri 9 am - 5 pm EST

Email Us

Accessibility

  1. Home
  2. Clearance
  3. Mix and Match
  4. Pencils

pencils

1-24 of 44 items
Make The Grade Pencils - 12 pencils.
Make The Grade Pencils - 12 pencils.
$4.99 $5.25
You save: $0.26 (5.0%)
(5.0)
100th Day Pencil - 12 pencils.
100th Day Pencil - 12 pencils.
$4.99 $5.25
You save: $0.26 (5.0%)
(3.6)
Birthday Cake Scented Pencils - 12 scented pencils
Birthday Cake Scented Pencils - 12 scented pencils
$4.99
(4.6)
Happy Birthday Pencils - set of 12 pencils.
Happy Birthday Pencils - set of 12 pencils.
$4.99 $5.25
You save: $0.26 (5.0%)
(5.0)
No. 2 Pencils - 48-Pack
No. 2 Pencils - 48-Pack
$8.29
Grade-Specific Welcome Pencils - 12 Pencils for K, 1st, 2nd or 3rd Grade
Grade-Specific Welcome Pencils - 12 Pencils for K, 1st, 2nd or 3rd Grade
$4.99 $5.25
You save: $0.26 (5.0%)
(5.0)
Birthday Bash Pencils - 12 pencils
Birthday Bash Pencils - 12 pencils
$4.99
(5.0)
Growth Mindset Pencils
Growth Mindset Pencils
$4.99
(5.0)
Happy Birthday From Your Teacher Pencils - 12 pencils
Happy Birthday From Your Teacher Pencils - 12 pencils
$4.99
(5.0)
Really Good Stuff® Paws Pencils - 12 pencils
Really Good Stuff® Paws Pencils - 12 pencils
$4.99
(5.0)
100th Day Of School Twinkler Pencils - 12 pencils
100th Day Of School Twinkler Pencils - 12 pencils
$4.99
(5.0)
Welcome To My Class Pencils - Sharpened - 12 sharpened pencils
Welcome To My Class Pencils - Sharpened - 12 sharpened pencils
$4.99
(5.0)
Happy Birthday Multi-Colored Pencils - 12 pencils
Happy Birthday Multi-Colored Pencils - 12 pencils
$4.99
(4.9)
Crayola® 240-ct. Colored Pencils Classpack®
Crayola® 240-ct. Colored Pencils Classpack®
$69.99
(5.0)
Drop Ship
Super Reader Pencils - 12 pencils
Super Reader Pencils - 12 pencils
$4.99
Cat In The Hat Pencils - 12 pack
Cat In The Hat Pencils - 12 pack
$4.99
(4.6)
Star Student Pizzazz Pencils - 12 pencils
Star Student Pizzazz Pencils - 12 pencils
$4.99
Dr. Seuss™ Giant Eraser Pencils - 36 pencils
Dr. Seuss™ Giant Eraser Pencils - 36 pencils
$34.49
(4.7)
Jumbo Kindergarten Pencils
Jumbo Kindergarten Pencils
$4.99
(4.9)
Happy Birthday Fiesta Pencils - 12 pencils
Happy Birthday Fiesta Pencils - 12 pencils
$4.99
(5.0)
Dr. Seuss™ Rainbow Writer Pencils - 12 pencils with toppers
Dr. Seuss™ Rainbow Writer Pencils - 12 pencils with toppers
$21.99
(5.0)
Really Good Stuff® Bubble-Gum Scented Pencils - 12 pencils
Really Good Stuff® Bubble-Gum Scented Pencils - 12 pencils
$4.99
(3.8)
Cat In The Hat Box Of 144 Pencils
Cat In The Hat Box Of 144 Pencils
$50.99
(5.0)
Colorations® Stubby Chubby Colored Pencils - Set of 48
Colorations® Stubby Chubby Colored Pencils - Set of 48
$29.99 $43.99
You save: $14.00 (32.0%)
Save when you buy 3 or more 12 Packs of Our Best Pencils!
Recommended For You
Colorations® Fine Line All-Purpose Easel Brush - Set of 60
Colorations® Fine Line All-Purpose Easel Brush - Set of 60
$46.47
Colorations® Best Value Hook and Loop Set
Colorations® Best Value Hook and Loop Set
$114.63
Environments® 20" Bright Pillows - Set of 6
Environments® 20" Bright Pillows - Set of 6
$199.99
Colorations® Extra-Safe Plastic Glitter, 1 lb. - Set of All 12
Colorations® Extra-Safe Plastic Glitter, 1 lb. - Set of All 12
$167.95
Colorations® Washable Chubby Markers Set of 256
Colorations® Washable Chubby Markers Set of 256
$79.99
Classroom Stacking Bins – Chalkboard – Set Of 6
Classroom Stacking Bins – Chalkboard – Set Of 6
$49.99 $59.99
Colorations® Wood Clothespins – Set Of 48
Colorations® Wood Clothespins – Set Of 48
$10.99
Word Building Sliders: Long Vowels
Word Building Sliders: Long Vowels
$41.98
Really Good Stuff® ELA Small Group Dry Erase Board Kit - Intermediate - 1 multi-item kit
Really Good Stuff® ELA Small Group Dry Erase Board Kit - Intermediate - 1 multi-item kit
$302.39
9" X 6" Mini-Magnetic Dry Erase Boards – Set Of 24 Boards, 24 Markers and 24 Erasers
9" X 6" Mini-Magnetic Dry Erase Boards – Set Of 24 Boards, 24 Markers and 24 Erasers
$173.99 $224.99
Really Good Stuff® Teacher Standing Desk - 1 standing desk
Really Good Stuff® Teacher Standing Desk - 1 standing desk
$309.99
Wiggle and Write Flexible Seat
Wiggle and Write Flexible Seat
$39.99
Really Good Stuff® Ready-To-Decorate® Self-Esteem Foldable Posters – Intermediate - 24 posters
Really Good Stuff® Ready-To-Decorate® Self-Esteem Foldable Posters – Intermediate - 24 posters
$11.25 $16.79
Programmable Monthly Calendar Jumbo Poster - 1 jumbo poster
Programmable Monthly Calendar Jumbo Poster - 1 jumbo poster
$17.99
Trash-It™ Subtraction Activity - 1 game
Trash-It™ Subtraction Activity - 1 game
$36.73